In an unusually-obsessive burst of TV viewing, I spent the last two weeks catching up on season 1 of Veronica Mars on DVD from Netflix.
VM is heir to the Buffy throne, in some ways — a blonde California high school girl with a single parent becomes an outcast as she uncovers the darkness around her. There are season-long story arcs, teenage angst, and crisp, sarcastic dialogue. Oh, and did I mention that Alyson Hannigan and (in season 2) Charisma Carpenter have recurring roles?
In fact, Joss Whedon is a huge fan of the series, and will guest-star in an episode airing on Nov. 9.
But the similarities end there. The series owes more to traditional detective fiction than anything else, although I’m not familiar enough with that genre to offer an enlightening comparison. Its setting is Neptune High, a school divided into the rich “09ers” and the poor kids whose parents flip the burgers and scrub the toilets. Veronica falls into the latter group — her father is the former sheriff, forced from office after he pursued a murder case too far, and is now a PI.
The victim of that murder was Lily Kane, Veronica’s best friend. Her attempts to solve the murder form one of the two overarching mysteries of season 1. The other is the question of who drugged and raped Veronica at a party.
Like I said, the series is a little dark.
While dealing with those issues, Veronica uses her deductive skills and her dad’s snooping devices to solve mysteries ranging from the inconsequential (missing poker night money) to the life-altering (true parentage). Unlike Buffy, she has no physical abilities, just a taser and a pit bull named Backup. She relies solely on her considerable wit and charm, which to me makes her a more appealing hero — and raises the tension when she is in physical danger.
Thematically, while Buffy was all about giving the evils of high school a demonic form, VM is more about the secrets that families keep and whether it’s better to know the awful truth or live in blissful ignorance.
The series isn’t perfect. The early episodes are a bit uneven, and there’s the occasional clunker (like the “hippie cult” episode). It features what might be the least-threatening motorcycle gang ever recorded on film (they even wear helmets). And honestly, Veronica needs to smoke — she’s a troubled teen AND a detective and she doesn’t smoke?! And yes, I know… did the world really need yet another drama series about beautiful California teenagers?
But give it a shot. It’s worth it.