Plan 9 Plans
At the moment, I have about a dozen vague ideas for my next spare-time creative project, and I’m stumbling from one to another until one strikes my fancy. One of these ideas is to, as a writing experiment, remake Plan 9 From Outer Space into something that doesn’t suck.
After all, at its core, the movie is about aliens who try to conquer the Earth by raising an army of zombies — you’d think that could be a seed for a decent action-horror flick. Besides, Hollywood always remakes the movies that were good to begin with. Why not take a crack at an awful one?
The finished script would go directly into a drawer upon completion, since the original is not public domain, but at least I would see if I could do it.
First of all, I was wildly wrong on that last count. Plan 9 apparently went into the public domain some time last year and I had no idea.
And of course, since it’s in the public domain, someone staked out an early claim and announced a remake, to be released on 9/9/2009.
At this point, I’m used to having a great idea, being too lazy to follow up on it, then seeing someone else do it — usually better than I ever could. I’m not sure that applies in this case, though. As Screenrant points out, the production company’s track record includes nothing but z-grade horror flicks, none with a budget higher than $8,000. Isn’t the idea here to make a GOOD version of Plan 9? Ed Wood already made the shitty version, and he did it in the most magically shitty possible way.
Io9′s post and comment thread on the topic is mostly filled with jackassery, but one commenter makes a good point I never realized, but probably should have:
Someone has already remade Plan 9 From Outer Space, and made it into a character-driven horror movie about people terrorized by the dead, reanimated by outer space phenomenon.
It was called Night of the Living Dead…
Huh. Zombies rising from the grave. Vague rumors of an alien origin of the plague. A house near a graveyard where most of the action takes place. It’s not that much of a stretch. Who knew that Plan 9 + talent = Night of the Living Dead?
The irony is, thanks to muddled business dealings, Romero’s film went into the public domain almost immediately, while Wood’s film was protected for 50 years. I wonder how many remakes, sequels, and spinoffs we can expect… and whether a major studio would take a shot at a big budget version or every last one will be shot on digicams in backyards for spare change.

